Shaken Margarita Recipe (on the Rocks)

To have the best Classic Margarita, you need the right ratio of tequila, lime juice, and orange liqueur. While most margaritas give you a taste that’s just average, this one will have you using it as your go-to recipe. I’ll show you how to make the perfect simple margarita every time using this classic ratio.

Why This is the Best Shaken Margarita Recipe

Have you ever noticed that there’s a big difference between a typical margarita and a great margarita? That’s because the way it’s made and the ingredients you use make a big difference in the end result.

Making a Classic Margarita is simple if you have the right recipe. Even if you want a flavored margarita, this recipe ratio will give you the ultimate base every single time.

This is the perfect margarita recipe because not only is it easy to make, but it’s perfectly balanced. I’ll teach you a ratio that’s easy to remember, just as quick as using the store-bought mixed stuff, but with a way better taste!

What does a margarita taste like?

There are three components that make a margarita taste like a margarita. Those are tequila, lime juice, and orange liqueur. 

The combination of these ingredients is what gives the margarita its recognizable flavor. Each of them brings that quintessential, classic taste of a margarita. 

Adding salt to the rim of the glass makes the margarita taste even better by balancing out the acidity of the lime juice.

All of these work together to make the perfectly balanced, delicious taste you know and love. 

What is a traditional margarita made of?

A margarita is a classic cocktail that’s made with tequila, lime juice, and orange liqueur. It is sometimes also made with simple syrup in addition to those three ingredients. 

The tequila is the base of the margarita. It’s important to use a good quality, great tasting blanco tequila. It should have a smooth flavor that mixes well with the other ingredients. 

The lime juice is what gives the entire margarita the tart flavor. I always recommend using fresh lime juice rather than bottled. 

While bottled lime juice is the more convenient option, it won’t give you the same flavor as fresh lime juice. 

Orange liqueur gives the margarita a touch of sweetness. I always recommend using either Cointreau, Triple Sec, or Grand Marnier for the best flavor. 

Simple syrup isn’t always included in traditional margaritas, but is optional. If you like a bit of sweetness in yours, I recommend adding the simple syrup. 

 Lime Margarita Ingredients

• Tequila – a blanco, high-quality, smooth tasting tequila will make a big difference
• Lime Juice  – always opt for fresh lime juice over bottled
• Orange Liqueur – I recommend Cointreau, Grand Marnier, or Triple Sec
• Simple Syrup (optional) – for a sweeter margarita use simple syrup, but you could also use agave syrup 
• Optional garnishes: limes, lime zest, coarse kosher salt, tajin

Easy Lime Margarita Recipe Substitutions

You can get creative with your margarita when substituting various ingredients. 

Substitute for Tequila in Margarita

To substitute tequila in a margarita, you could use vodka, rum, mezcal, whiskey, or even brandy. 

Tequila is a key ingredient for margaritas so using any of these substitutes will give you a different flavor and won’t make it a classic margarita. Vodka may give it a more neutral taste, while rum may give it a sweeter taste. Mezcal will give it a unique smoky flavor. 

If you do decide to use rum as a substitute, you’ll want to omit the simple syrup and possibly lower the amount of orange liqueur to control the sweetness level. 

Orange Liqueur Substitute for Margaritas

While there are many different types of orange liqueur, if you’re looking for a non-alcoholic substitute, there are options. 

You can use orange juice or orange extract. Orange juice will give the margarita a tart flavor, while orange extract will give it a really concentrated orange flavor. 

If you decide to opt for orange juice, you’ll want to be aware of the amount of lime juice in your margarita. Because both are tart, too much will ruin the overall flavor and taste. 

Swapping out orange liqueur for orange juice will also change the alcohol content of the margarita. One using orange juice will have a lower alcohol content than a margarita using orange liqueur. 

Lime juice substitute for margaritas

A quick and easy substitution for lime juice is fresh lemon juice. Lemon juice has a very similar tart flavor and will give you similar overall taste. 

As with the lime juice, I do recommend using fresh lemon juice and not using the bottled kind. While it’s an easy shortcut, it does make a big difference in overall taste and flavor. 

Substitute for Triple Sec in Margarita

Yes, you can use Cointreau instead of Triple Sec. Both Cointreau and Triple Sec are orange liqueurs, but Cointreau is a higher-quality version. 

How to make a Margarita on the Rocks

Making a classic margarita on the rocks is simple! Here’s how:

1. To a cocktail shaker (or you can use a mason jar), add ice, tequila, lime juice, orange liqueur, and simple syrup. 
2. Shake vigorously until the ingredients are fully mixed together. 
3. Pour the margarita over ice cubes into a salt-rimmed glass and enjoy!

Lime Margarita on the Rocks Recipe Variations

There are so many possibilities when it comes to changing up the classic margarita. The combinations and possibilities are endless. 

Frozen margarita: Take this same recipe and blend it with ice for a frozen version of the classic. 

Strawberry margarita: For a fruity twist, add muddled strawberries to the shaker before shaking. The fresh fruit is perfect for summer! 

Spicy margarita: Chopped jalapeños add a kick of heat to the traditional recipe. You can also roast them before adding them in for a smoky flavor.

Pineapple margarita: To make a fun, tropical version, add pineapple juice to the margarita before shaking. 

Watermelon margarita: Add fresh watermelon juice to the classic margarita recipe to give it a sweet, cool twist. You can also muddle watermelon in the bottom of the glass before pouring in the shaken margarita.

Mezcal margarita: Swap out the tequila for Mezcal for a smoky version. 

Cucumber margarita: Muddle some cucumbers into the shaker glass before adding the rest of the ingredients for a refreshing version. 

Margarita on the Rocks Recipe tips

• Always use a smooth tasting, high quality tequila. A bad tasting tequila will make a bad tasting margarita. You want it to be smooth with a slightly sweet flavor. 
• Go with fresh lime juice. While bottled lime juice might feel like a quick shortcut, it can really change the flavor. You’ll be able to really taste the difference between fresh and bottled. 
• Go easy on the simple syrup. Adding too much simple syrup takes away from the classic taste of a margarita. 
• Salt your glass! Even if you’re making it at home, don’t skip the salted rim. 
• Be sure to always serve it cold. No one likes a warm margarita. Be sure you serve it chilled over ice or blend it if you prefer. 

What to Serve with this Lime Margarita Recipe

To serve a classic margarita, start by rimming your glass with salt. It’s optional, but adds great flavor! Just run a lime wedge around the rim of the glass and dip it into a shallow dish of coarse salt. Coarse kosher salt or sea salt work great. You don’t need to buy any special margarita salt.

Add ice to the glass and pour the margarita over ice. Garnish with a lime and enjoy! 

Tools you’ll need for Lime Margarita on the Rocks

shot glass measuring cup

Buy Now →

cocktail shaker

Buy Now →

cocktail glass

Buy Now →

Shaken Margarita Recipe Storage

Refrigerator: Add the margarita (without ice) to an airtight container and place it in the refrigerator for up to 24 hours. 

Freezer: Pour the margaritas into ice cube trays or freezer molds and freeze them completely. Once they’ve frozen, you can remove them from the trays and molds and add them to an airtight container or freezer-safe zip-top container. 

Margarita Recipe Rocks FAQs

What to serve with homemade margaritas

A fresh margarita is the perfect side-kick to Taco Tuesday or a Cinco de Mayo celebration. Here are some of my favorite taco recipes to serve with margaritas:

• Chili Lime Shrimp Tacos
• Shredded Beef Tacos
• Crockpot Chicken Tacos

If you make this recipe and love it, we would love a 5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ rating! It helps us continue to provide free recipes.